The time has come to talk about hoarders; believe it or not, there is a DOG under all that feces! What kind of person thinks they are giving this animal a loving home? I watch the show because these people fascinate/horrify me, and I'm really torn as to the validity of this condition. Some episodes, like the poor man who let those rats take over his entire house, show a person clearly in need of help. The man's much-loved wife died of a heart attack, and he got 3 pet rats to keep him company; one of the rats escaped the cage, and THIS was the result:
I raise rats myself in order to feed our snakes and my tarantula, and I've had them escape on several different occasions (I learned my lesson well though--and now I keep all my rats in 20-gallon aquariums with metal mesh lids; no rat can chew through glass!!), but I always caught/killed them within a few days because I know full well the horrendous damage they can cause. This man, who has all my sympathy, lost his whole house and everything in it; these rats simply destroyed it. As I was watching this episode, something kept nagging me in the back of my mind; something was missing/wrong about those rats and I couldn't put my finger on it until the show was over--and then I realized. There were NO baby or juvenile rats anywhere in that house. Why? Because the adults ATE them; both for food, and as a means to control their own population. They do this whether in the wild or in captivity.
Anyway, the man in this story clearly had issues which needed addressing, so I believe that the hoarding diagnosis fit him. The problem I have with the diagnosis of hoarding today is very like that of all those children being diagnosed with ADD or ADHD years ago; it became a self-propagating epidemic, and the drug Ritalin became the Holy Grail for many parents with kids who were just energetic (I personally knew quite a few parents who took their kids to the pediatrician and insisted they be placed on the drug, merely for behavioral control; I thought those parents were & are despicable). I think that there are many many people today who are misdiagnosed as being a hoarder when they're in fact lazy slobs. Take this photo for example, of a hoarder's house:
The hoarders who live in this house are book collectors; they didn't really think they had a problem until the husband developed a serious heart condition and the couple realized that, should he have a heart attack or needed medical attention, the EMS team had no hope of entering the home and saving his life. People with undiagnosed mental illness frequently do not understand that there is a problem; which is a very big clue in the diagnosis! Now, take a look at this:
This house is a whole other kettle of fish. There is no collecting going on here, unless you count garbage as a collection! I believe this is not hoarding--the person who let this happen is disgusting and lazy. There is no excuse for this. It's not a mental illness if you're too lazy to take your garbage out to the curb & wash your dishes! But yeah, there IS something terribly wrong with a person who lives like this--it's just not called hoarding.








